Joan of Arc, Saint or Sinner?

Comments on article "Joan of Arc, Saint or Sinner?"
Name Views and CommentsDate
Noubi God does not bully his followers around, but sometimes we do not fully understand the message of God and we interprit things the way we think it is. Joan may not understood all the message she had, but she was certainly not just another sinner. In a way, she was special... even that we do no know how special. Several things were certain, she did good in many ways. 12/17/2010
POLLY ST. RAPH I PERSONALLY HAVE RECEIVED GREAT AWARENESS OF SAINT JOAN'S ABILITY AND HER GOODNESS. I HAVE HAD MIRACLES OBTAINED BY HER AND WE HAD A FAMILY MEMBER NAMED AFTER HER IN HER HONOR. SHE TRULY
LOVED JESUS AND SHE IS A FRIEND TO PRESENT OUR PRAYERS THROUGH HER TO JESUS. THE CATHOLIC CHURCH DOES NOT HAVE IDOLS JUST MANY
GREAT SAINTS WHO LOVED JESUS, HIS MOTHER, SAINTS AND ANGELS AND ABOVE ALL THE FATHER IN HEAVEN SO HOW CAN WE NOT LOVE THEM AND PRAY TO THEM AS FRIENDS...THEY LOVED, HAD FAITH...HOW DARE ANYONE DENY SUCH HOLY ONES THEIR RIGHTFUL PLACE...IN THE BIBLE IN JUDE IT SPEAKS OF PEOPLE WHO DO NOT HAVE ADEQUATE FAITH...		 7/25/2010
P. ST. RAPHAEL I VISITED DOMREYME IN FRANCE AND WHERE SAINT JOAN WAS BORN AND WHERE SHE DIED. I LEARNED VERY MUCH AND I WILL NEVER CALL HER ANYTHING BUT A SAINT...FOR ANYONE'S INFORMATION OUR HOLY LORD JESUS CAME TO SAVE SINNERS AND SINNERS CAN BECOME SAINTS IF THEY PURIFY AND REPENT...JUDGEMENT BELONGS TO GOD IN THE FINAL END FOR ALL PEOPLE AND GOD CAN CHOOSE WHOMEVER HE WILLS TO DO HIS WORK...THERE ARE SO MANY WASTEFUL AND SHALLOW ARGUMENTS AND GAMES PLAYED BY THOSE WHO HAVE NOTHING TO DO BUT HARRASS CHRISTIANS INSTEAD OF LEARNING IN A REALLY CORRECT WAY...THERE ARE THOSE WHO SLANDER THINGS SACRED AND SMUGLY SIT AS IF THEY ARE WISE. SAINT JOAN DID MORE FOR FRANCE AND THE WORLD THAN MANY WHO SAY THEY DO NOT BELIEVE IN GOD AND WORK DAY AND NIGHT TO DESTROY THE FAITH. FRANCE IS A VERY SPECIAL COUNTRY...THEY ARE TAKING A STAND AT THIS TIME AGAINST EVILS OF THE DAY AND I AM CONVINCED
THAT SAINT JOAN'S PRAYERS HAVE HELPED.		 7/25/2010
POLLY ST. RAPH I PERSONALLY HAVE RECEIVED GREAT AWARENESS OF SAINT JOAN'S ABILITY AND HER GOODNESS. I HAVE HAD MIRACLES OBTAINED BY HER AND WE HAD A FAMILY MEMBER NAMED AFTER HER IN HER HONOR. SHE TRULY
LOVED JESUS AND SHE IS A FRIEND TO PRESENT OUR PRAYERS THROUGH HER TO JESUS. THE CATHOLIC CHURCH DOES NOT HAVE IDOLS JUST MANY
GREAT SAINTS WHO LOVED JESUS, HIS MOTHER, SAINTS AND ANGELS AND ABOVE ALL THE FATHER IN HEAVEN SO HOW CAN WE NOT LOVE THEM AND PRAY TO THEM AS FRIENDS...THEY LOVED, HAD FAITH...HOW DARE ANYONE DENY SUCH HOLY ONES THEIR RIGHTFUL PLACE...IN THE BIBLE IN JUDE IT SPEAKS OF PEOPLE WHO DO NOT HAVE ADEQUATE FAITH...		 7/25/2010
Wild and Crazy Wow! now that you stop and think about it could it be true could my role model real have been just another sinner? Does God real do such a think as not caring? Hard to believe if you real stop and think about it. Do you think that's why we don't? 11/8/2009
just a girl God does not deceive his followers. It is natural to blame someone when you are in a bad situation. Why is it so impossible that Joan of arc actually was hearing god? Joan was a good person. Just because she messed around a bit does not make her a witch. 10/21/2009
Hannah how can she be a sinner? im doing a history fair project on her and i know for sure that she is definatly not a sinner. 10/17/2008
joe cirello i love joan 8/24/2008
joe cirello dear people joan is like my name joe and she was burned in her barefeet and ive had a foot fetish for years and years i excepted jesus when i was young praise be to joan of ark thank you joe cirello 8/24/2008
emma I found it helpful it pesuaded me to do a project on her 6/10/2008
emily To really understand Joan of Arc you need to have a complete knowledge of her life. There is a great deal of history available online and maidofheaven(don)com is probably the most comprehensive of all the Joan of Arc sites. Try reading her quotes for great insight in to who she really was. Her trial records are also very interesing to read. 6/5/2008
Use the feedback form below to submit your comments.
Your Comments:
Your Name:
Use the form below to email this article to your friends.
Recipient Email Address:
 Separate multiple email addresses by ;
Your Name:
Your Email Address:
More History Articles