| Name |
Views and Comments | Date |
| aikaterini |
the macedonia is greek |
10/25/2009 |
| Ierakas |
If you are talking to me, "a turkey" I will remind you what happened after 1821, when we were liberated.
The best is coming.
Wait... |
9/26/2009 |
| A Turk |
The best defats others.
You remained under the "yoke of Turks".
This means Turks were better than you. |
9/9/2009 |
| Ierakas |
And not to forget, Dr Turkommatis:
Congratulations for the election of Erdogan.
Your predictions were again very...accurate.
You are so funny, Dr Jekyl |
8/7/2007 |
| Ierakas |
The only criminal around here is the Dr Jekyl Megalommatis who knows as much history as I know astronomy. Look my previous comment, anhistorical "historian" to see the ancient historians describing the Greek Macedonians. For the before 1912 comment of yours is another lie in the very long list of your propaganda.
And here is the proof:
Megalommatis, did you read the news?
The New York times. Tuesday, August 31, 1886:"The news which our London correspondent cables us is extremely warlike. It is no new thing for half the population of London and Paris to be firmly convinced that Europe is on the verge of a general war, but in the present case there is a much better foundation for that startling belief than is usually the case.
The return of ALEXANDER to Bulgaria is of course a terrible affront to Russia, and the other powers are doubtless not far wrong in expecting her to show some resentment, perhaps a great deal. The report that it is the purpose of the powers friendly to ALEXANDER, to aid him in the forcible annexation of Macedonia or a part of it to his kingdom may be set down as somewhat premature, we imagine.
This would involve the young Bulgarian King in precisely such a crime as the Czar is evidently willing to commit in seizing Bulgaria, for Macedonia is Greek, not Slav, by preponderance of population, and to unite her with Bulgaria would set Greece in a terrible, frenzy, besides being a real wrong upon her people".
So, Macedonia is Greek, not slav. Is this a greek propaganda too?
Whoever is interested I can send the pdf file of the photocopied 1886 newspaper.
Useless to repeat that YOU are useless and not ar all professor but an unsuccessful clerical worker :Employment 2005 December – 2006 June: (the official website of the Governorate of Alexandria – Egypt). Actually, after 2006 you are probably unemployed. |
8/7/2007 |
| MSMegalommatis |
Useless to repeat it:
Macedonia was never Greek before 1912!
Prof. Dr. Muhammad Shamsaddin Megalommatis |
7/26/2007 |
| MSMegalommatis |
It is very idiotic and absolutely criminal to use the signature of another person to continuously diffuse Greek, anti-Macedonian, paranoiac and nationalistic trash that is rejected already in Greece!
This shows what sort of filthy characters are the supporters of ludicrous Antonis Samaras, the Kalamata Slav who envisioned that he could be of Greek ancestry! |
7/26/2007 |
| MSMegalommatis |
I am absolutely wrong. Macedonia is part of Greece and always was Greek land |
5/26/2007 |
| ierakas |
This is the answer of an illeterate nazi turkey.
I give books here Dr Turkomatis.
Read them and express opinion afterwards |
5/26/2007 |
| MSMegalommatis |
No answer to illiterate neo-Nazi Greeks! |
5/26/2007 |
| ierakas |
I now realized what you said at the last paragraph which make me feel that your histoical knowledge is not higher than mine for astronautics!
"I am sure you know that, as early as 1600 or 1700, there was not a single Greek family in the Ionian Sea, in the Balkans, in the Aegean Sea, in Anatolia, in Pontus or in Istanbul to have such a name: 'Kallinikos' is not a genuine, historical Greek name (like Komnenos, etc). It is a modern construction."
Some books from the thousands for several Kallinikous in much earlier than 16th century age:
A Psychoanalytic History of the Jews - Page 218
by Avner Falk - 1996 In the west Seleukos Kallinikos fought for Asia Minor against his younger brother
Journal of Sacred Literature and Biblical Record, April 1863 to July 1863 - Page 494 by B. Harris Cowper - 2003 - 516 pages ‘The Kallinikos who addressed the letters to the London papers on the subject of
the Codex Sinaiticus "
Kings and Colonists: Aspects of Macedonian Imperialism - Page 95
by Richard A. Billows – 1995 "governing Karia under the Seleukid ruler Seleukos II Kallinikos, a 3rd century grave stone mentioning"
The Thracians, 700 BC-46 AD - Page 47
by Christopher L. Webber, Angus (ILT) McBride - 2001 - 48 pages
M.Lucullus (governor of Thrace and Macedonia in the 70s BC) was attacked by the
... G: THE KALLINIKOS SKIRMISH, 171 BC In this action, a prelude to the
Rome and Her Enemies: An Empire Created and Destroyed by War - Page 84
by Jane Penrose - 2005 - 304 pages
... victorious Thracian troops returned to their camp after the Kallinikos skirmish,
swaggering, singing and dancing, with severed Roman heads as trophies
The Cities of Seleukid Syria - Page 249
by John D. Grainger, ( - 1990 - 272 pages
... 154—5, 156- 7, 162 Demetrios II Kallinikos, king 132, 155, 157-61, 162, 163,
... 86; founded by Seleukos 46 Europos (Macedonia) 65 evidence, paucity of,
Byzantine Empresses: Women and Power in Byzantium, AD 527-1204 - Page 46
by Lynda Garland - 1999 - 368 pages
... 'adai the creator of the ‘Jacobite' church, to be held first at Kallinikos on
the Persian border, and then Dara, but, despite great concessions on the
The Kingfisher History Encyclopedia - Page 100
by Kingfisher Books - 2004 - 491 pages
V Byzantium was often under attack. Its navy had a secret weapon invented by
Kallinikos in 677 called ‘Greek Fire," a mixture that burst into flames when it
In the liquid fire of Kallinikos the lies will be destroyed, dr Bigmatis-I hope you will accept the humour with your name-
Ierakas again
|
4/28/2007 |
| ierakas |
Dr Megalommatis,
Surprised that you use sources of wikipedia and forums despite your academic background
Neo-Nazi Greeks: First historic mistake from somebody who should have heard that the first victory against "axis" was Greek against Italians. Also, it is very well known the "Ethniki Antistasi" struggle against Germans and the Battle of Crete where Nazis lost the most significant part of their parachutists-German grave at Chanea is the "witness" of that. I will continue the "number game since you liked it so much. Of course the so-called "anti-macedonian hysteria" is hilarious: As if you accuse the Americans for …anti-texanism.
1. Since you need e-mails against your opinions I will add my humble opposition to your theories which are against all historical evidences (and all odds)
2. I am impressed from your CV although it is a weapon and can be used either way: Support or kill the truth. So, in your case is important who you are but since you express opinions against the common knowledge (and sense) it is also important WHAT you are saying.
3. Since there are opinions of refusing ancient authors because they were Greek, it is important to say that you are Turk. Nothing wrong with that except that Turkey is responsible for genocides of 3 nations which have never been accepted by the Turkish state. The Germans have accepted their responsibilities ONLY partially: they still haven’t made up for the atrocities against the Greek people and for the gold they have stolen. On the contrary, we see today countries allied to Nazis having tremendous support like Croatia; Serbs who fought against Hitler have been seriously damaged. In turkey crimes still take place against Kurds and Armenians, killers are having pictures with policemen and maniacs are killing innocents in Christian bookstores
4. Speaking for necrolatrous is a word that I didn’t expect to hear from a historian and his job and life is to study dead people. So necrolatrous shouldn’t be bad when we see history. Again, is Demosthenes history? An orator is not a historian. His opinion is not stronger from today’s politicians and fanatics characterizing other politicians as "enemies of the country and non-Greeks" According to Arrian, Anabasis of Alexander II, 14, 4 (Loeb P.A. Brunt) Macedonia is part of Greece:» Your ancestors invaded Macedonia and the rest of Greece and did us great harm though we had done them no prior injury;... I have been appointed hegemon of Greeks...». Strabo - VII Frg. 9 (Loeb, H.L. Jones):"Macedonia, of course, is part of Greece". And of course Herodotus V, 20, 4 (Loeb A.D. Godley)
"Tell your king who sent you how his Greek viceroy of Macedonia has received you hospitably..." "Now that these descendants of Perdiccas are Greeks, as they themselves say, I myself chance to know» Herodotus V, 22, 1 (Loeb A.D. Godley) and a small help from mythology, Hesiod: "And she conceived and bore to Zeus who delights in the thunderbolt two sons, Magnes and Macedon, rejoicing in horses, who dwell round-about Pieria and Olympus",
Hesiod Catalogues of Women and Eoiae 3 (Loeb, H.G. Evelyn-White). Also Polybius: "This is a sworn treaty made between us, Hannibal ... and Xenophanes the Athenian ... in the presence of all the gods who possess Macedonia and the rest of Greece."
(Pol. Histories, VII, 9, 4 [Loeb, W.R. Paton]). Plenty of proofs in the Bible for the Greekness of ancient Macedonia: Isaiah 66:19 Isaiah 66:18-20 Isaiah 66 Ezekiel 27:13 Ezekiel 27:12-14 Daniel 8:21 Daniel 8:20-22 Daniel 10:20 Daniel 10:19-21 Daniel 11:2 Daniel 11:1-3 Zechariah 9:13 Zechariah 9:12-14 Acts 20:1 Acts 20:1-3 Acts 20:2 Acts 20:1. And for your… third, or whatever, country: History of reading, Steven Roger Fischer, p 57: «The library of Alexandria was begun under Alexander's successor, the Macedonian Greek ruler Ptolemy I Soter". Of course the argument about the so-called "Greek-Macedonian" fight is farcical: Philip fought against Thebans and Atheneans but it was common for the Greek cities (Poleis) to fight each other for leadership (Hegemony) e.g. Spartans against Atheneans (Pelloponesian war). Also, Philip fought against the other Macedonian tribes to become their leader. Of course there are thousand of proofs for the Greekness of Alexander that himself declared in every single chance and now they say that he was doing "propaganda".
5. You changed your family name to Megalommatis but with all due respect, I don’t believe that they denied to change your name back to the Turkish original name especially if the application was recently and not … in the 40’s. There are thousands of Greek names ending in –oglou there is no question that you will be accepted as on more –oglou. I think that this case "Vgazei ommati" as non-real in modern world. Of course is easier the Megalommatis than the other-sorry I can’t spell it correctly
6. "Whatever the country might be". Correct. Even if "country" means killing Christian priests, journalists, terrorizing minorities and threatening other countries-Iraq, Cyprus, Greece- for invasion and in the case of Cyprus has already happened.
7. You have nothing against Greece and Greece has nothing against you. But you should take the example of Orhan Pamuk and make comments for the condition in your country of origin instead of suggesting to millions of population which example should follow.
8. Very good idea: one country, earth. When there will be NO borders anywhere anyone can declare him/herself Macedonian. Till that time, we will protect the nations.
9. Accusing somebody for "paranoid, nationalistic paroxysm" just because he suggested you to do something that you have already tried to do-although failed- makes you a bit worse than the accused person
10. Kallinikov? Is that a suggestion from a respectful historian? Maybe the name…Farmerayroglou can be used in case that somebody wants to change his Greek name because he is Turk
And if my Grand-grand father was Filipino I wouldn’t really bother and I would be proud of him as I am sure you are for your Greek mother
Ierakas
|
4/28/2007 |
| poliplatanos |
istor=brad=neo greek nazis |
4/9/2007 |
| MSMegalommatis |
Neo-Nazists are those who diffuse the idea that the Macedonians are Greeks.
Period. |
4/9/2007 |
| Brad Banks |
As if his previous total distortion of history wasn't bad enough in his first article, you now allow his racist ramblings to be published..
Its a shame but at least we know that whoever indicates his intentional distortions is a neo-nazi.. |
4/9/2007 |
| Istor |
I see no word about my comments!
Istor
Macedonian, therefore Greek. |
4/9/2007 | |
