Sarkozy's voodoo doll remains on shop shelves
French president, Nicolas Sarkozy, loses case to have voodoo doll in his image withdrawn from circulation.
The French president, Nicolas Sarkozy, has lost in his attempt to have a voodoo doll in his image, withdrawn from circulation here in France.
A Paris court has ruled that they may remain on sale.
A couple of weeks ago, Sarkozy had instructed his lawyer, Thierry Herzog, to file a law suit claiming that the doll was a "misuse of the president's image" and demanding it be withdrawn.
But on Wednesday a court ruled that the "non-authorised representation of the image of Nicolas Sarkozy neither constituted an affront on the human dignity (of the president) nor a personal attack."
The doll comes as part of a kit, complete with 12 needles and an instruction manual on how to use it.
It includes such delightful quotes, characteristics and policy decisions from the French president such as; "The end of advertising on public television, "Work more to earn more" or the infamous faux pas during his visit to the annual agricultural fair earlier this year when he told a visitor who refused to shake his hand to "Get lost you stupid (expletive deleted)" and invites users to stick pins in the appropriate place.
It has been on sale since the beginning of October, but through his lawyer, Sarkozy had protested that he had exclusive rights to his own image.
While acknowledging that the doll hardly represented the "best of taste", the court maintained that users couldn't "take seriously the procedure and believe that they were indeed practising voodoo."
It also stressed that both Sarkozy and his opponent in last year's presidential run-off, Ségelone Royal (who also has a similar doll on sale) had both put played heavily to the electorate in terms of focusing on their public image as part of their promotional campaign.
Royal - who had not taken legal action against the manufacturers - said that she welcomed the court's decision as "good news".
K&B, the company which has manufactured and distributed the manuals and dolls (Sarkozy - 20,000, Royal, 15,000) will be allowed to continue selling the items.
Herzog has not yet said whether Sarkozy will be appealing the court's ruling.
A Paris court has ruled that they may remain on sale.
A couple of weeks ago, Sarkozy had instructed his lawyer, Thierry Herzog, to file a law suit claiming that the doll was a "misuse of the president's image" and demanding it be withdrawn.
But on Wednesday a court ruled that the "non-authorised representation of the image of Nicolas Sarkozy neither constituted an affront on the human dignity (of the president) nor a personal attack."
The doll comes as part of a kit, complete with 12 needles and an instruction manual on how to use it.
It includes such delightful quotes, characteristics and policy decisions from the French president such as; "The end of advertising on public television, "Work more to earn more" or the infamous faux pas during his visit to the annual agricultural fair earlier this year when he told a visitor who refused to shake his hand to "Get lost you stupid (expletive deleted)" and invites users to stick pins in the appropriate place.
It has been on sale since the beginning of October, but through his lawyer, Sarkozy had protested that he had exclusive rights to his own image.
While acknowledging that the doll hardly represented the "best of taste", the court maintained that users couldn't "take seriously the procedure and believe that they were indeed practising voodoo."
It also stressed that both Sarkozy and his opponent in last year's presidential run-off, Ségelone Royal (who also has a similar doll on sale) had both put played heavily to the electorate in terms of focusing on their public image as part of their promotional campaign.
Royal - who had not taken legal action against the manufacturers - said that she welcomed the court's decision as "good news".
K&B, the company which has manufactured and distributed the manuals and dolls (Sarkozy - 20,000, Royal, 15,000) will be allowed to continue selling the items.
Herzog has not yet said whether Sarkozy will be appealing the court's ruling.
Use the feedback form below to submit your comments.
Use the form below to email this article to your friends.
- Nicolas Sarkozy - National Hero
- Profile: Nicolas Sarkozy
- Confusion over Sarkozy's December meeting with Dalai Lama
- Sarkozy taking action - legal action
- Sarkozy urges multi-lateral action to stop piracy at sea
- Sarkozy takes a chance in Syria
- Sarkozy to meet Dalai Lama - in December
- Sarkozy spin or a cave in to Chinese pressure?
- Sarkozy says Ireland should vote again
- Sarkozy's "astonishing" Olympic announcement
- Sarkozy's G8 Ennui
- Sarkozy's union-bashing barb
- Sarkozy minds his manners - and other's
- Sarkozy's Sexist Blunder?
- Sarkozy starts visit to Israel
- Sarkozy muscles in on EU reform
- A taxing day as Sarkozy goes walkabout among the fruit and veg
- Sarkozy outs himself as Céline fan
- Sarkozy sees sense on Blair presidency
- Sarkozy’s First Year In Office
- Sarkozy and Obama: No Love Lost?