Router Vs Switch Vs Hub

What do we get when we compare 'router vs switch vs hub'? Are you interested in the differences between routers and switches and hubs? Well, read on!
Router Vs Switch Vs Hub
Most of you who are into computer networking would be familiar with the concept of a router, a switch and a hub. Therefore, a comparison chart based on 'router vs switch vs hub' is something that would be on the tip of your lips. However, for those of you who aren't all that familiar with these networking devices, here is a small introductory article in which we will look at the difference between routers and switches, the difference between switches and hubs, and also the difference between routers and hubs.

Router Vs Switch Vs Hub - An Introduction
Basically, these three are nothing but computer networking devices which are used to connect two or more computers across a single network, or across multiple networks. Each of these devices has its own set of individual properties and networking suitabilities. The following sections of this article will give you a clearer picture regarding the comparison between switch vs hub, router vs switch, and router vs hub.

Switch Vs Hub
Here is a tabular representation of the differences between a switch and a hub.

Switch Hub
As per the OSI model, network switches are classified as Data Link Layer devices, i.e. they operate at Layer 2. However, certain multi-layer switches can operate at higher layers as well. As per the OSI model, a hub is a Physical Layer device, i.e. it operates at Layer 1.
A switch is a more sophisticated network device and is more expensive than a hub. A hub is a very primitive device and is comparatively much cheaper.
A switch is an intelligent device, it transmits the data packets from the source computer to only those network computers to which the data packets are originally intended. A hub is a 'dumb' device to say the least. It broadcasts the data packets to each and every networked computer, and not just the target computer or set of computers to which the data packets were originally intended to be sent.
There is optimum utilization of network bandwidth in case of switches, and bandwidth wastage is minimal. Due to their broadcast mechanism of data transmission, there is unnecessary wastage of network bandwidth which results in slow operation and data transfer speeds.
Switches are full-duplex devices, i.e. both, data transmission and reception can take place simultaneously. Hubs are half-duplex devices, i.e. both, data transmission and reception cannot take place simultaneously.
Network security is much better with the use of a switch, as compared to a hub. Thanks to its broadcast mechanism, network security becomes a big issue and a loophole in the case of a hub.

You can read more on 'what is a hub'.

Router Vs Switch
Here are some points of comparison which highlight the differences between a router and a switch.

Router Switch
Basically, a router is used to connect computers belonging to one network with those belonging to another or other networks. Thus, a router connects two or more different networks. A switch on the other hand, connects different computers within one network.
As per the OSI model, a router is a Network Layer device, i.e. it operates at Layer 3. Unless it is a multi-layer switch, a network switch operates at Layer 2 (Data Link Layer).
Routers are much more sophisticated and intelligent network devices, as compared to switches. In comparison with routers, switches are less sophisticated and less intelligent.
A router works on the principle of IP addresses. A switch works on the basis of MAC addresses.
A router's inbuilt hardware makes use of routing algorithms to compute the best possible path for routing data packets across different computer networks. A switch does not perform any such activities.
Routers have their own inbuilt operating systems and they need to be configured before use. Most switches do not require any prior configuration and are usually 'ready-to-use'.

You can read more on computer networking basics and how to find an IP address.

This was a short comparison regarding 'router vs switch vs hub'. I hope the above tables would have given you a good idea of the functionalities of these three networking devices and their differences.

By Parashar Joshi
Published: 11/10/2009
Use the feedback form below to submit your comments.
Your Comments:
Your Name:
Use the form below to email this article to your friends.
Recipient Email Address:
 Separate multiple email addresses by ;
Your Name:
Your Email Address: