Quartz Vs. Granite Countertops

Are you thinking of installing a new countertop in your kitchen but are not able to decide if it should be a quartz or granite countertop? Has the quartz vs. granite countertops debate gone too far in your head? The following article discusses some pros and cons of both quartz and granite countertops, which we hope will help you take your decision.
Quartz Vs. Granite Countertops
Quartz Countertops
Quartz is found in very large quantities on our planet and is a very hard substance even in its crude form. Diamond, sapphire and topaz are the only minerals that are more scratch-resistant than quartz. If we go by the Mohs' Hardness scale, which is used to determine the scratch resistance capacity of a mineral, quartz is ranked 7 on this scale while diamond is ranked 10. Quartz countertops that are available today consist of 93 percent quartz while the remaining 7 percent is made up of other minerals. This peculiar composition makes the quartz countertops naturally hard and extremely durable to use. As compared to granite kitchen countertops, quartz countertops are less porous, due to which food particles and other liquids do not stick to the countertop's surface. Also cleaning and removing stains from a quartz countertop is far easier than from a granite countertop.

If we consider engineered quartz countertops, they are available in a wide range of solid colors. Also, the color of an engineered quartz countertop surface is uniform throughout, which is not the case for a granite countertop. Engineered countertops do not need sealing either and are easier and cheaper to install. However, after installation, the joints of an engineered quartz countertop are easily visible which hampers its overall appearance. Such joints are not visible in case of granite countertop installation.

Granite Countertops
Granite, on the other hand, is also a strong and dense material when extracted from the earth. It is available in the form of huge blocks which are later broken in smaller pieces of slab according to individual requirements. These granite slabs are then polished using an application of resin or polyurethane sealer which makes the granite water proof. Granite countertops are more vulnerable to contamination due to the growth of bacteria. A mild detergent and warm water can however, solve this problem. The quantity of quartz in granite countertop is only 50%, which is far lesser than its quantity in a quartz countertop. Due to this, granite countertops are less harder and also less crack-resistant. To get the record straight, a granite countertop is only half as hard and durable as a quartz countertop.

Installing a granite slab is a very laborious and tedious task due to which the installation can cost almost three times the amount spent on the slab. Granite also requires an additional supporting structure during the installation as it is very heavy. However, once a granite countertop is installed, it becomes a permanent structure. Removing it later can even harm the adjoining structures. The biggest advantage of granite countertops is that they sport a luminous surface and give a very rich look to the kitchen furniture.

Here is a brief overview of quartz vs. granite countertops.
  • Granite countertops are more porous than quartz.
  • Granite countertops are more vulnerable to staining than quartz.
  • Granite countertops are less resistant to growth of bacteria.
  • Granite countertops are not available in a uniform color surface while quartz countertops are.
  • Granite countertops add more value to the overall furniture in the house.
While installing a countertop in your kitchen, it is wise to remember that once installed, the countertop becomes an integral feature of the house and you must take every measure to ensure that it adds value to the existing look of the house. So one must thoroughly evaluate the properties of both granite and quartz countertops and also the monetary constraints before finally installing them.

By Rohit Bandri
Published: 7/15/2009
 
Use the feedback form below to submit your comments.
Your Comments:
Your Name:
Use the form below to email this article to your friends.
Recipient Email Address:
 Separate multiple email addresses by ;
Your Name:
Your Email Address: