Ruling Brands Judaism Racist – Chief Rabbi
Sir Jonathan Sacks issues a rallying cry for Jews to defend their schools from English law
The Chief Rabbi, Sir Jonathan Sacks, issued a rallying cry for Jews today to defend their schools from English law after the court of appeal decided that admission on the basis of a parent's Jewish status was discriminatory. Writing in this week's Jewish Chronicle, he condemned the ruling, saying it branded Judaism "racist".
His comments follow last month's judgment by the court of appeal that a Jewish school that prioritized applications from children with Jewish mothers discriminated on grounds of race. Seen as a landmark decision on the admissions criteria used by faith schools, the case centered on a boy known as M, 12, who was refused admission to JFS, in Brent, London.
M, a Jew who regularly attends a progressive synagogue, was told he could not be admitted because his mother had converted to Judaism in a procedure not recognised by the Chief Rabbi.
Overturning a previous judgment in favor of the school, the court said a policy determining eligibility based on a person's descent, rather than religious practice, amounted to racial discrimination.
Sacks wrote that Jewish education was extended to Jews, "that is, those born of Jewish mothers" or those who had converted according to the standards of the religious authority to which the school belonged. It was a religious, not a racial, test and it applied to all Jewish schools, "Orthodox and non-Orthodox alike".
"An English court has declared this rule racist, and since this is an essential element of Jewish law, it is in effect declaring Judaism racist," Sacks wrote. "To be told now that Judaism is racist is distressing. To confuse religion and race is a mistake."Faith schools are exempted from the law prohibiting discrimination on grounds of religion or belief, to enable them to provide education in line with their beliefs."Once [a faith school] is oversubscribed, it can restrict entry to children whom – or whose parents – it regards as sharing the school's faith," the court said. "No school, however, is permitted to discriminate in its admissions policy on racial grounds."
His comments follow last month's judgment by the court of appeal that a Jewish school that prioritized applications from children with Jewish mothers discriminated on grounds of race. Seen as a landmark decision on the admissions criteria used by faith schools, the case centered on a boy known as M, 12, who was refused admission to JFS, in Brent, London.
M, a Jew who regularly attends a progressive synagogue, was told he could not be admitted because his mother had converted to Judaism in a procedure not recognised by the Chief Rabbi.
Overturning a previous judgment in favor of the school, the court said a policy determining eligibility based on a person's descent, rather than religious practice, amounted to racial discrimination.
Sacks wrote that Jewish education was extended to Jews, "that is, those born of Jewish mothers" or those who had converted according to the standards of the religious authority to which the school belonged. It was a religious, not a racial, test and it applied to all Jewish schools, "Orthodox and non-Orthodox alike".
"An English court has declared this rule racist, and since this is an essential element of Jewish law, it is in effect declaring Judaism racist," Sacks wrote. "To be told now that Judaism is racist is distressing. To confuse religion and race is a mistake."Faith schools are exempted from the law prohibiting discrimination on grounds of religion or belief, to enable them to provide education in line with their beliefs."Once [a faith school] is oversubscribed, it can restrict entry to children whom – or whose parents – it regards as sharing the school's faith," the court said. "No school, however, is permitted to discriminate in its admissions policy on racial grounds."
Use the feedback form below to submit your comments.
Use the form below to email this article to your friends.
- Greek Socialists Achieve Resounding Win in Snap Election
- David Cameron Warned Over Tory Human Rights Stance
- Barack Obama: All the President's Emails
- David Cameron Retreats on European Referendum
- Lindsay Lohan Takes Centre Stage at Ungaro Show in Paris
- Ireland Votes in Favour of Lisbon Treaty
- David Letterman Haunted By the Ghosts of Sex Jokes Past
- Why Roman Polanski Just Loves the English Courts
- John Gotti Jr Trial: Best Friend of Accused Mafia Boss Turns Informer
- Two Million Slum Children Die Every Year As India Booms