Judge Quashes Restrictions on Muslim Convert
Control order on terror suspect lifted as High Court warns about danger of guilt by association
A control order on a British convert to Islam was quashed yesterday when a high court judge ruled there was no "reasonable suspicion" that he intended to take part in terrorism abroad.
MI5 had alleged that the restriction of movement measures were necessary because Cerie Bullivant, 25, of Dagenham, Essex, could be planning to travel to Iraq or Afghanistan to join up with terrorists.
Mr Justice Collins quashed the order, which was made last year to replace an order made in June 2006.
The first order was triggered when Bullivant was stopped at Heathrow as he was about to fly to Syria. He had been traveling with Ibrahim Adam, the brother of fertilizer bomb plotter Anthony Garcia, and said he intended to study Arabic.
The Security Service judged that he and Adam intended "to carry out extremist Islamic activity" - possibly intending to travel on to Iraq or Afghanistan to fight against western forces, or to conduct a "martyrdom operation".
Mr Justice Collins said it may have been reasonable to assume that individuals with whom Bullivant associated might have been involved in terrorism, but that did not make it reasonable to suspect he had the same inclinations. "The dangers of guilt by association are obvious."
Bullivant said outside court in a statement: "Although I am very happy that this order has now been lifted, this draconian legislation is still continuing to ruin the lives of others and their families."
MI5 had alleged that the restriction of movement measures were necessary because Cerie Bullivant, 25, of Dagenham, Essex, could be planning to travel to Iraq or Afghanistan to join up with terrorists.
Mr Justice Collins quashed the order, which was made last year to replace an order made in June 2006.
The first order was triggered when Bullivant was stopped at Heathrow as he was about to fly to Syria. He had been traveling with Ibrahim Adam, the brother of fertilizer bomb plotter Anthony Garcia, and said he intended to study Arabic.
The Security Service judged that he and Adam intended "to carry out extremist Islamic activity" - possibly intending to travel on to Iraq or Afghanistan to fight against western forces, or to conduct a "martyrdom operation".
Mr Justice Collins said it may have been reasonable to assume that individuals with whom Bullivant associated might have been involved in terrorism, but that did not make it reasonable to suspect he had the same inclinations. "The dangers of guilt by association are obvious."
Bullivant said outside court in a statement: "Although I am very happy that this order has now been lifted, this draconian legislation is still continuing to ruin the lives of others and their families."
Use the feedback form below to submit your comments.
Use the form below to email this article to your friends.
- Feds Rate Travelers on How Likely They Are to be Terrorists
- Jamaica Slums Locked in Violence, Report Says
- World Plea to Brown Over Detention Bill
- Top Blair Aide: We Must Talk to Al-qaida
- Forget the Rolexes, Fake Ferrari Proves $600bn Industry Has Moved Up a Gear
- Found: the Boy Caught in Kenya's Bloody Hell
- Three Arrested in Denmark Over Plot to Kill Muhammad Cartoonist
- UK Orders Hamza's Extradition to Us
- Dozen Killed As Sri Lanka Marks Independence
- Violence Fear Over Islam Film
- US Considers Tighter Travel Rules for European Visitors
- 'We Must Win the Debate at a Level of Hearts and Minds'
- 'You've Got to Show That Civil Liberties Are Protected'
- Muslim British Resident in Spanish Jail for Two Years Without Charge
- Serb General Gets 33 Years' Jail for Role in Siege of Sarajevo
- Positioning Before Principle
- Brother of Accused Pilot Wins Damages for 9/11 Arrest
- Is "Second Life" a Virtual Training Ground for Terrorists?
- Feds Agree to Pay Oregon Man $2 Million for Wrongly Arresting Him
- Innocent Man Killed By Police in London Subway, Not a Terrorist