For Brown, Money is Key to the Middle East
The next PM sees the world's most intractable conflict as an opportunity for economic development, but misses some of the wider political issues, says Ian Black.
Britain is giving full support to the new Palestinian emergency government and wants to help it make a success of running the West Bank despite the uncertainty following Hamas's armed takeover of the Gaza Strip, one of Gordon Brown's closest aides said today.
Ed Balls, economic secretary to the Treasury, warmly endorsed the interim independent prime minister, Salam Fayyad — a former World Bank official — as he surveyed prospects for economic development in the Palestinian territories. "What's happening in Gaza is terrible but this is a moment of opportunity in the West Bank," he told the Royal Institute for International Affairs in London.
Mr Balls is tipped for a senior ministerial post when Mr Brown takes over from Tony Blair on June 27. "Achieving lasting stability and security in the Middle East will be a high priority for the next prime minister," he said. "The shocking violence we saw in Gaza highlights the need to address its root causes."
In late 2005 he was asked to conduct a study for the finance ministers of the G8 on how to rebuild the economy of the region. That was after Israel's unilateral withdrawal from the Gaza Strip but before Hamas won the Palestinian elections, triggering a controversial international financial boycott to force the Islamist movement to change policy.
The Quartet of Middle East peacemakers demanded Hamas recognize Israel, end violence and respect existing peace agreements between Israel and the PLO and refused to deal with it when it failed to do so explicitly. Quartet policy did not change when Hamas joined a Saudi-backed national unity government with the secular Fatah movement.
"If you have an administration in the West Bank that will meet the Quartet principles then the test will be the way the international community and Israel respond," Mr Balls said.
"Economic development can only ever play a supporting role in the politics of the road map, and ... significant economic steps forward are unrealistic without political progress and progress on security," he added
But the overall impression of a keenly awaited speech was that a Brown government will see the world's most intractable conflict primarily through the prism of economic development, when in fact several fundamental political issues — settlements, borders, refugees and Jerusalem — have to be tackled. The G8 project was co-led by the Treasury's Jon Cunliffe, who is to be Mr Brown's adviser on international economics and EU issues.
In a related move, the international development secretary, Hilary Benn, announced that the UK was donating £1m for emergency aid to be distributed in Gaza by UNRWA, the UN agency dealing with Palestinian refugees, to be used for healthcare, food, and rebuilding water and sanitation facilities.
Mr Balls focused on the "staggering disparity" between Israel's high-tech, innovative and globally linked economy, and a Palestinian one that is still dependent on agriculture and low-value goods with "bleak" prospects for development
Despite $10bn in international aid since the Israel-PLO Oslo agreement in 1993, 65% of Palestinians now live below the poverty line compared with 20% in 1998. A macro-economic crisis can only be averted through a credible Palestinian Authority-led budget plan, he said, calling for both a lowering of the wage bill and for Israel to release withheld tax revenues.
"The Palestinian economy had to diversify and reduce its dependence on Israel, though there is no medium-term solution to Israeli security without a Palestinian economic relationship with Israel," he said. "The access and mobility this requires will require a degree of trust and cooperation between the Israeli and Palestinian governments which today looks remote and which will require great leadership to secure."
Mr Balls acknowledged the threat Israel faces from Palestinian terrorist attacks but added: "Security restrictions seriously constrain Palestinian economic development and are a big obstacle to prosperity. And although targeted at extremists who seek to undermine peace, the restrictions impact equally on the majority of moderate Palestinians who seek a negotiated settlement."
Ed Balls, economic secretary to the Treasury, warmly endorsed the interim independent prime minister, Salam Fayyad — a former World Bank official — as he surveyed prospects for economic development in the Palestinian territories. "What's happening in Gaza is terrible but this is a moment of opportunity in the West Bank," he told the Royal Institute for International Affairs in London.
Mr Balls is tipped for a senior ministerial post when Mr Brown takes over from Tony Blair on June 27. "Achieving lasting stability and security in the Middle East will be a high priority for the next prime minister," he said. "The shocking violence we saw in Gaza highlights the need to address its root causes."
In late 2005 he was asked to conduct a study for the finance ministers of the G8 on how to rebuild the economy of the region. That was after Israel's unilateral withdrawal from the Gaza Strip but before Hamas won the Palestinian elections, triggering a controversial international financial boycott to force the Islamist movement to change policy.
The Quartet of Middle East peacemakers demanded Hamas recognize Israel, end violence and respect existing peace agreements between Israel and the PLO and refused to deal with it when it failed to do so explicitly. Quartet policy did not change when Hamas joined a Saudi-backed national unity government with the secular Fatah movement.
"If you have an administration in the West Bank that will meet the Quartet principles then the test will be the way the international community and Israel respond," Mr Balls said.
"Economic development can only ever play a supporting role in the politics of the road map, and ... significant economic steps forward are unrealistic without political progress and progress on security," he added
But the overall impression of a keenly awaited speech was that a Brown government will see the world's most intractable conflict primarily through the prism of economic development, when in fact several fundamental political issues — settlements, borders, refugees and Jerusalem — have to be tackled. The G8 project was co-led by the Treasury's Jon Cunliffe, who is to be Mr Brown's adviser on international economics and EU issues.
In a related move, the international development secretary, Hilary Benn, announced that the UK was donating £1m for emergency aid to be distributed in Gaza by UNRWA, the UN agency dealing with Palestinian refugees, to be used for healthcare, food, and rebuilding water and sanitation facilities.
Mr Balls focused on the "staggering disparity" between Israel's high-tech, innovative and globally linked economy, and a Palestinian one that is still dependent on agriculture and low-value goods with "bleak" prospects for development
Despite $10bn in international aid since the Israel-PLO Oslo agreement in 1993, 65% of Palestinians now live below the poverty line compared with 20% in 1998. A macro-economic crisis can only be averted through a credible Palestinian Authority-led budget plan, he said, calling for both a lowering of the wage bill and for Israel to release withheld tax revenues.
"The Palestinian economy had to diversify and reduce its dependence on Israel, though there is no medium-term solution to Israeli security without a Palestinian economic relationship with Israel," he said. "The access and mobility this requires will require a degree of trust and cooperation between the Israeli and Palestinian governments which today looks remote and which will require great leadership to secure."
Mr Balls acknowledged the threat Israel faces from Palestinian terrorist attacks but added: "Security restrictions seriously constrain Palestinian economic development and are a big obstacle to prosperity. And although targeted at extremists who seek to undermine peace, the restrictions impact equally on the majority of moderate Palestinians who seek a negotiated settlement."

Use the feedback form below to submit your comments.

Use the form below to email this article to your friends.

- Making Contact With Middle East Reality
- A Small, Slender Chance for Peace in the Middle East
- At Last, Consensus in the Middle East: All Agree These Talks Are Bound to Fail
- Saudi Arabia's Revived Plan For Middle East Peace
- Condi Rice Off to Middle East - With No New Ideas
- Berlin Signals New Tack Over Middle East
- The Final Place of Refuge for Christians in the Middle East is Under Threat
- If Europe Doesn't Want Middle East War to Begin Again, It Has to Step Up
- Lebanon and the Middle East Timeline: July 2006
- The King of Fairyland Will Never Grasp the Realities of the Middle East
- All at Sea in the Middle East's Perfect Storm
- The Middle East Reaction to the Danish Cartoon Row
- Iran and Israel Will Be Kings of the Middle East Jungle
- Bush's Vision Fails to Win Over Middle East
- The Carve-up of Iraq Will Spawn a Redivision of the Middle East
- Bush's Dream of Democratic Middle East May Rest on Engaging With Islamists
- Pressure for Democracy in the Middle East
- Middle East Sees Benefits of Bush
- David Hirst on the Middle East in 2003
- US Thinktanks Give Lessons in Foreign Policy
- Obama Makes Strong Push for Two State Solution in Middle East
- Obama to Arabic Network: U.S. is Not Your Enemy



